Understand foie gras, how it is made, why it is controversial, and what it means for French food, animal rights, and traditional gastronomy.
What is foie gras and why it matters in French food
Foie gras is a traditional French food product made from the liver of a duck or goose that has been fattened through a specific feeding process. It is associated with gastronomic traditions in the southwest of France, especially in regions such as Périgord, Landes, and Alsace. In French law, foie gras is defined as the liver of a duck or goose fattened by force-feeding (also called gavage).
Foie gras is served in slices, in terrines, or lightly cooked as a starter in a French meal. It is also used in fine dining restaurants across France and exported widely. France remains the largest producer and consumer of foie gras in the world, with over 18,000 tonnes produced annually, most of it from duck liver.
The price of foie gras varies widely. A 300g (10.5 oz) jar of duck foie gras can cost around €30 (approx. £26 or \$32) in shops. Goose foie gras is rarer and can reach €50 (approx. £43 or \$53) for the same quantity.
How foie gras is made: technique and regions
The gavage process
The method used to produce foie gras is called gavage, which involves feeding ducks or geese two to three times per day for about 12 to 18 days using a feeding tube. The feed is usually corn mash, and the goal is to enlarge the liver significantly.
The result is a liver weighing 400 to 600 grams (14 to 21 oz), several times larger than the natural size. This technique has existed since ancient Egypt and was later developed in Roman and Jewish communities, before becoming widespread in France during the 18th century.
Main production areas
Most foie gras in France is made from mulard ducks, a sterile hybrid. The leading regions for foie gras production include:
- Landes and Gers in southwest France, where duck foie gras dominates.
- Alsace, which historically specialized in goose foie gras, though production has declined.
- Occitanie and Nouvelle-Aquitaine also contribute significantly.
France accounts for around 70% of global foie gras production. Hungary and Bulgaria are also major producers, especially of goose foie gras, which is less common today.
The controversy: animal welfare and legal debates
Animal rights concerns
The main controversy surrounding foie gras involves animal welfare. Animal protection groups argue that force-feeding causes pain, liver disease, and distress in ducks and geese. A study by INRAE (the French National Institute for Agriculture) confirmed that gavage leads to hepatic steatosis, a form of fatty liver disease.
Some veterinarians and scientists suggest that the birds adapt to the process due to their anatomy, as ducks and geese have non-gagging esophagi. Others maintain that the enlarged liver is pathological, and not just a culinary preference.
Bans and legal restrictions
Several countries and cities have banned the production or sale of foie gras. These include:
- India, which banned imports in 2014.
- California, where foie gras production is illegal since 2012, and sales were also restricted, though the law has faced legal challenges.
- New York City, which voted in 2019 to ban foie gras sales from 2022. Implementation has been delayed.
- In the UK, production is banned, and a potential import ban was discussed but not adopted.
In France, foie gras is protected by law as part of the country’s gastronomic heritage. The French Ministry of Agriculture continues to support the industry.
Economic and cultural importance in France
Foie gras is deeply linked to the French identity, especially during end-of-year celebrations. More than 70% of foie gras consumed in France is eaten in December, often as part of festive meals.
The foie gras industry supports around 30,000 jobs in France, including farmers, processors, and distributors. Most of them are located in rural areas. Protected Geographical Indication (IGP) labels exist for foie gras from regions such as Périgord and Gascogne, ensuring quality and traceability.
Alternative methods and ethical foie gras
Non-force-fed foie gras
In recent years, some producers have tried to create foie gras without gavage. In the Gers department, the company Ethic Valley raises ducks that are fed normally and develop fatty livers naturally over time.
A Spanish producer, Eduardo Sousa, is known for his free-range geese, which are fed figs and acorns. The resulting foie gras is more expensive and not identical in texture or taste, but is marketed as ethical foie gras.
These products remain limited in quantity and often cost over €100 (approx. £86 or \$106) for a 180g (6.3 oz) jar. They are mostly sold in niche markets or high-end restaurants.
Scientific innovation
Some startups have also explored lab-grown foie gras, using cell culture techniques. French company Gourmey, based in Paris, received funding to develop foie gras from duck liver cells. The product is still in development and has not reached commercial scale.
Nutritional and culinary aspects
Foie gras is rich in fat, with about 45% fat content. A 100g portion contains around 450 kcal. It is also a source of iron, copper, and vitamin B12. Its texture and flavor are valued in French cuisine, especially when served with brioche or fig jam.
In cooking, foie gras can be served cold in terrines, or hot, lightly seared in a pan. It is often paired with sweet wines, like Sauternes or Monbazillac.
Foie gras today: between tradition and criticism
Foie gras continues to be a symbol of eating in France for many people. It represents tradition, craftsmanship, and festive meals. For others, it raises questions about animal welfare and the ethics of food production.
Public opinion in France is divided. A 2020 poll by Ifop showed that 47% of French people support banning force-feeding, while 52% still consume foie gras during holidays.
The debate is not only ethical but also cultural and economic. It raises questions about how to reconcile traditional practices with changing social values.
Cook in France is your gateway to French cuisine and gastronomy in France. Get in touch for your next cooking workshop.